Saturday, May 10, 2014

Planned Fate

Harvey Lee Oswald, to say the least, is an interesting character. Although I've followed him for almost an entire book now, I still feel like the I don't know him.  Sometimes I think I know who he is, or that I've established  my feelings about him, he changes my mind. I guess it's good because it keeps the plot riveting. However it becomes very difficult to understand the plot (if you don't understand the character, you won't understand his motivations for his action, then you won't understand what's making the plot  move forward) Right now, I definitely feel like Lee is a tragic figure. (And hate him less).

From my perspective, all he seems to want is  attention (might be due to childhood trauma ).  He wants to have secrets so people value his presence. However I've never understood how being a part of the flow will help that; if he's just another person in a cool plot, he's still just one person. However if he were to step out of that flow and establish himself as an individual he may be respected and valued (or ignored since he doesn't have any connection. It can go either way...). Ferrie points it out and, I assume, Lee is listening but pretending he doesn't care right now. The sad part is that Lee thinks he's found someone who "understands"(or pretends to understand) him but it might just be another set up. Ferrie tells Lee everything he ever wants to hear-- lee's destiny--but it's just a scam. If his role in the plot is so important, people will value him but we find out that TJ is just going to kill him later on; he's just a cover up; everything Ferrie is telling him is a lie.  It's his destiny? BS. It's more like there's a layer of strings being pulled that we're aware of and another layer that we don't know so we call a coincidence. His fate was decided by those other forces the moment they laid eyes on  Lee.

Moments like this make me sympathetic to Lee. I really dislike that he's so obsessed with a belief that he can't  have a normal life anymore.  [What I mean is that, when he drops all names of people he's connected to and making himself seem more important that he actually is, he's calling attention to himself; attention that get rid of. So basically his shortsighted bites him in the butt because the CIA etc won't leave him  alone. ] he wants his wife to live with him but she won't. He's alone.  It's sad.  Maybe if Marina had agreed to move in with him again, would he still feel the need to do what he did? The answer depends on what you feel is the driving force for Lee's actions. I feel like maybe he wouldn't have...

Anyways, reading this book it's easy to forget this is FICTION. When I do decide to come back to reality and not live in Delilo's/Branch's world,  I wonder what the write thinks of Lee. Since I can't get a grip on Lee, I'm having a hard time seeing what the authors trying to portray Lee as: sympathetic or just obsessed with fame or pitiful or not guilty since his life was basically planned but levels upon level of conspiracy theories? I don't know. Hopefully the scene of the Kennedy assassination is narrated from Lees point of view so I can see what the author uses as an excuse for Lee's action.



3 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Whoops, sorry about that previous comment; I messed something up and had to delete it since it's apparently impossible to edit it.

    I agree that Lee's situation is unfortunate bordering on tragic, but let's not be so quick to accuse David Ferrie. David, as far as I can discern, truly believed what he was telling Lee. Yes, he was trying to psychologically manipulate Lee, but he did believe that the two of them would be taken to Cuba through Mexico. His grief and panic after Lee is arrested and assassinated is genuine, and he is truly shaken by how badly his vision of the future got derailed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, in DeLillo, Ferrie is a dupe almost as much as Lee--they aren't really telling him much about the master plan, and they don't listen at all to his apparently genuine concern about what will happen to Lee afterward. He is trying to get Lee to "do a job" here, but Lee is still one of "his boys," and I agree that his grief and panic are genuine.

      And of course, this is all within the novel's fictional frame. Although Oswald did inexplicably have David Ferries' New Orleans library card in his wallet when he was arrested on 11/22/63, Ferrie denied ever having met him, and he never acknowledged any contact with Lee Oswald at all.

      Delete