Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Billy Pilgrim =(ish) Harvey Lee Oswald ?

Reading the specially chosen books in class, I often find (maybe just totally hallucinating) parallels between the characters. I can't help it, it's a habit!

Anyways, as the title suggests, I am seeing Billy-ish characteristics in HLO; only some so I'm not going to cry if you're not convinced. [Again, yes I acknowledge the many difference in their personalities. They are different characters and are meant to represent different things.]

Billy and HLO have a childlike characteristic.    
  Billy is childlike in that he isn't really aware (innocence) of the things that are going on and has this filtered perception of things.
   HLO is childlike because he throws 'tantrums'. As someone mentioned in class, HLO seems like a kid who wants attention [i.e from the KBG]  and demands his ways through badly thought out plans [i.e shooting his arm; committing suicide]. [On that note, I would like to comment that I don't think HLO is impressive. He carries out his plans, yes, but his plans are ... things that first come to your mind when you get really pissed off. Likeeeeee, if someone purposefully steps on your feet, you want blow their feet off so they never step on your feet again? I don't know…They, the plans, don't require courage, but just a lack of common sense/emotional stability]


A detachment from what's happening and other things I can't pinpoint.  
     Weary was narrating the story as he was going through the war: The Three Musketeers. HLO narrates his actions from a distant also (as discussed in class). Yes he's no Billy, but just thought I'd throw it in there. There are things that HLO does that aren't really because he wants to, but because 'it's time'. Such as losing his virginity. It wasn't that he had raging hormones like other soldiers during WWI, he slept with the prostitute because it was about time he did it. It's just as Billy and the Tralfamadorian philosophy of time being structured that way and there isn't a 'why'. He too did things without wanting to or really had a reason for. For example, when Billy had sex with his wife, he was narrating it almost; there was no emotions. Just like HLO's experience. [It's really just a list of similarities I see, it might not make coherent sense as a paragraph.]

I also think that the stories of both these characters undermine their image. Billy isn't anything like a war hero. Harvey, who's admirable because he actually pull off this stunt, is undermined by all his failures and 'weird' personality. 
ALSO: They both also find faults in their environment and have crazy ideas that aren't 'appreciated' where they are. (They're both also emotionally unstable…)

Friday, April 11, 2014

#flashbackfriday

Excuse the annoying title but I couldn't resist:)

I've been trying to expand on this idea but I really don't know where else to go with it?

There was one day in class we've talked about Rufus, but in a very specific manner and it spawn this idea: Rufus parallels Doctrow's Younger Brother, and Tom Weylin parallels Father.

Rufus is very similar to Younger Brother in that his character being "easily"(and I use the term loosely) influenced by others. Younger Brother after meeting Goldman gets ideas about being revolutionary and starts seeing flaws in his family and being upset with the way things are. Similarly, after meeting Dana and hearing about her world, Rufus also starts to dislike his environment (but for him, it's because he isn't allowed to 'be' with Alice). For both of them, after meeting that one fateful woman, their life starts on a dangerous path(very different oaths, and for different reasons but the overall idea is very much the same). We also can't forget their tragic ending.

As for Father and Tom Weylin, they're both figures that remain pretty much unchanged throughout the novel and are a product of the time. For example, when Father asks Coalhouse if he knew any coon songs. He didn't mean to be offensive or anything; it was just all that he knew. Same with Tom Weylin when winks at Dana(again I acknowledge the many differences between the examples). Both don't think they're doing anything wrong, but their actions make us cringe. Although at least towards the end, Weylin sort of acknowledges Dana's value when he trusts her to heal his son, showing some change. Father however remains unchanged towards the end of the novel.

This claim is a very surface level claim because the dynamics of the characters are different and the issues they face are different; I know all that. But it struck me and I had to share!

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Choo Choo

[Totally unrelated to my post but had strong urge to confess: Ok. I'm going to come out and say, I don't like Dana. I don't like her self righteousness. I don't appreciate her controlling personality. I especially dislike how she can't realize that this is really what life was like, and that it's time to face her history instead of changing it or criticizing it. ]

After a while of reading these books and having discussions on how they have purposes, I can't help but wonder what Octavia's message is. It's been driving me insane really because I have to read to find the message while dealing with the main character, who I don't like. 

Here were all the crazy conspiracy theories I came up with ( I see some of them are far fetched, but humor me): 

1. a backlash versus the proud american culture that refuses to see fault within itself 
2. a push for acceptance of our history, ALL of it, because the bad parts push for people to change
3. Dana's as annoying as heck because Octavia wants the reader to see that it's easier for someone looking back to say they'll change this and that, but when placed in the situation, it's not actually that easy
4. a claim that the world isn't ready for all this liberal stuff [meaning interracial marriage], thus drawing parallels between Kevin and Dana's relationship with Rufus and Alice's
5. all these ideas (except 4…)revolve around some big idea that I'm totally missing

I can make arguments for all of those theories, some stronger than others. However I probably lose you if I try to explain them all.  So I'll humor you with one since you humored me. 

I'll explain… [5]. 
All of my train of thought run out of evidence to drive on at some point, but if I put all of the ideas together I can see something all the ideas have in common, thus having enough track to have a 'completed' idea. I believe that Octavia is saying, to put it simply,  is that it's ok to make mistakes; just admit them and take responsibility.  
Well, throughout the story, Dana's a stand in for the reader. She reacts the way people of our time would if they were placed in that position. [Maybe it's not a spot-on a stand for you, but it's close enough.] She goes through the whole journey influencing Rufus and imposing upon him her modern ideals. [This can result in confusion in Rufus who has the ideals of a [technologically advanced noun] but the methods of achieving those ideals of a [ non technologically advanced noun]. I believe that that's why Alice is being put through this(+ other things). The hope for a marriage like Dana and Kevin's drives his desire for Alice.] Dana is also very self righteous. She sees all these things that were really the dynamics of the time and looks at them with her modern lens and criticizing everything. She can't accept that things, especially people of her lineage actually participating in this. It's kind of like how Americans trying to cover up their bombing on hiroshima(too extreme? sorry) or other things because they can't admit to themselves that they did this and that mankind isn't on an upward trajectory. They, as in the 'majority?' won't stand for things that will make them question the core of their institution, so they push it aside or act like if they went back they would change it. I'm really not saying accept in the sense that these things are ok, but that they happened. However it's because of them that mankind move forward and know what not to do. So yup.