Tuesday, March 4, 2014

The Complexities of an Old Fart


The narrator in the first chapter states that this book is written by a pillar of salt. It is a failure. But, due to being in the mindset of Mumbo Jumbo, I can't help but think that there's more to that. That it's not just some blasphemy a war-traumatized old fart made up but some blasphemy a SMART war-traumatized old fart made up...

His causal tone and the 'out there' ness of his 'so it goes' almost demands a second glance. Much like how Doctorow, breezes past the fact regarding the child labor, Vonnegut breezes past mothers getting incinerated in bombing sessions. Is this a sly demand for attention? Or is it a cover up?

Cover Up?
Yes. So that the higher up people don't see this as a question to their authority! Maybe Vonnegut was hinting it at in chapter 1 when he said that he was a pillar of salt for looking back when he wasn't suppose to. Looking back does have a lot of meaning... It could mean to remember and relive the moments. It could also mean to question the information you're given and looking back and sort through the mess yourself and develop your own conclusions about the rationality of what you were forced to do. I think in this context, it's the second meaning of 'looking back'. People of high up authority who ordered the war don't want that. They want mindless young men who are blinded by the glory, not gore, of war to kill who they're told to kill. They don't want the soldiers to think of the enemy civilians as human beings. They try not to shed too much light onto what's that bullet going through.  That's why, this book could get so risky; it can make the people on the other side of the gun seem human. AND remind the people holding the guns they're human too.

To avoid getting expose for his criticism, Vonnegut underplays everything. Just like Mumbo Jumbo, he makes it seem like there is no plot to the story and he's just a crazy old fart. But old farts are very smart you see; they make things seem like a joke, so to dare you to point out that it's not. that killing people is not ok either. that wars are stupid. that books aren't what they seem.

1 comment:

  1. Wow--this is an interesting idea, and I think you're right that Vonnegut deliberately undermines his own authority in chap. 1 in part as a way to *assert* it. Like calling his book a "failure" (usually, not the sharpest marketing move!)--there's some irony here, in that he may have "failed" to produce an exciting, coherent narrative; or he has "failed" to depict the war as a just and necessary "duty dance" that brave soldiers rose up to fight; he has "failed" even to "just write what happened" and instead has produces this "jumbled" book. But as we've been talking about in class, in some ways the "jumble" makes more sense than a "line" as a model for how to tell a "true war story." (Weary's story, in contrast--the one about the "Three Musketeers"--is formally more conventional; it just happens to be totally false.)

    ReplyDelete