Relation?
Both people in these 'nonfiction' narratives claimed they went through some horrific or difficult event that evoked the sympathy from thousands, or even millions of people. Outraged were americans when news broke out that neither authors actually took part in their 'memoirs.'
FYI:
[The Woman Who Wasn't There was a documentary about a woman who had claimed to be a survivor of the 9/11 terrorist attack. Her story made headlines; millions saw her as a hero, while fellow survivors looked to her for comfort. The story she fabricated soon falls apart at the seams when evidence is uncovered that she wasn't even in the US when 9/11 took place.]
As consumers, we trade; we give to get. When we read non-fiction, we allow ourselves to [give] trust to the piece of writing. We trust that what we're reading is based purely on fact (although I don't that that history is PURELY based on fact but that's besides the point), without fabrication. Along with that trust we're making ourselves vulnerable to the stories. So when things as traumatic as battling addiction or being a survivor happens to an individual within that piece of nonfiction, it makes the event seem more real that if you wrote a story about battling addiction. Within a fictional story, feelings of sympathy will be called to the surface but they will be gone, and sometimes forgotten after the book is closed. However when we know what we're reading has happened in real life, it's inspiring to know that another human is capable of doing something like. It spawns hope and admiration for the individual.
In this situation, that glimmer of light is diminished when you realized you're reading fiction.
The author might have gotten it from a great source, but the writer has never actually gone through it. And to claim that he or she has, it's like mocking the people who actually went through it. It angers people when the author claim to be one of 'them', making it seem as if their pain is easily evoked.
So all that inspiration and admiration wilts away when you realize your worse nightmares are true; that you can't surpass this struggle; that it's only in fiction. I don't know about you, but I would be angry with the person who lead me on.
The Woman Who Wasn't There raises issues similar to Frey (the guy who wrote the memoir about his alcoholism). The sense of "betrayal" they evoke is reflected nicely in the way you describe the "glimmer of light" that comes along with what we take to be a personal, first-hand testimonial. The author seems to be confiding in the reader, gaining our trust and sympathy and understanding, revealing shameful parts of themselves in order to strengthen and edify all of us. It's akin to other forms of deception, and a form a lying, in fact: claiming to be what one is not, or to have done something one has not done. It *does* seem to matter to us, sometimes, whether a work is fictional or not.
ReplyDeleteOr, maybe it's that such people seem so free to treat their own lives as fiction that it repels our sense of decency. That is, if TWWWT were to have written a *novel* about a 9/11 survivor, that was as persuasive and convincing in its detail as her personal testimonial, readers might have responded similarly--we would know that the "fictional" character reflects a lot of real-life experiences people actually went through, and we still would believe we were gaining some insight into such an unimaginable experience. It's in the "author" claiming to actually *be* that person that offends us. That's more of a straight-up LIE than a creative FICTION.
Great post! You bring up a lot of interesting ideas. It's true that saying fiction is nonfiction can seem deceitful, but I also think there's room for creativity, especially when telling your own story. For example, I love David Sedaris's memoirs, but I don't really expect everything he says to be true because a lot of it just so outlandish, I know he's using creative license. There are ways in which we edit our memories so that they make more sense to us or so that they fit into the greater meta-narrative, and this all comes across when putting our stories into print. To consider these outright lies isn't exactly true, but it could have more to do with the delicacy of how we choose to tell our stories.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading around, I've finally come to terms with myself that fiction, in so many ways, is like history. But simple reading the description of "The Woman Who Wasn't There" made me feel so let down and even a bit angry, especially after hearing that, before it was discovered that she wasn't even there, so many survivors looked up to her. This all leads me to believe that fiction and history are totally different, especially when it comes to how the people react emotionally to them. But maybe I feel offended because this documentary was fiction presented as history. If this movie was presented as fiction, I would still stand by my idea that history and fiction are very similar, for I still think people could learn from it because everything stated in it would still be realistic.
ReplyDeleteI think that for the average person (by that I mean non-historian), history and fiction are both equally "real" to them. I will never live in ancient Rome any more than I will in Middle-Earth. I can't relate to Winston Churchill any more than I can to Bilbo Baggins. Actually that's a lie, I relate way more to Bilbo Baggins. Either way, my point is that fiction is just as, if not more, emotionally touching as history. How often have you finished a particularly intense book, and put it down with the sudden realization that no one around you just experienced the emotional roller-coaster that you did? That being said, you raise a good point, a lot of the anger from finding out a "historical" story is fiction comes from being lied to, because being angry about being lied to is a natural human response.
ReplyDelete