Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Let the Mumbo Jumbo become Ragtime

If you've noticed it, then this post will reinforce your idea! But it's probably just me, because this is pushing it a little…

First off, to ease you into the idea, some surface level similarities:
Coalhouse, Is That You???

  • Both the plot's location is in New York. 
  • (From Class Discussion) Both have to do with music; Ragtime with Ragtime, Mumbo Jumbo relating to Jazz
  • Post Modernist Touch: Occurring in a projected world similar to ours but those events never happened in our world; characters' worlds overlap so everyone knows everyone else.
  • Time Frame are relatively close to each other
  • Dealt with things that shake America
  • Idea revolves around the African American community
  • Charity Ball and Rent Parties are both sponsored by the very rich with so much time
  • 'Transfictional' characters (Coalhouse, Von Vampton)
Now.  A explanation is in order. 
As Mumbo Jumbo progresses, it still makes very little sense. Like Ragtime in the beginning. Both the authors take a long time developing and clearing up the plot line. Both start off by telling the stories of individuals that will later come together for one big climax (maybe in mumbo jumbo, I don't really know). [I'd like to say that maybe the similarities arise due to the fact that they are both touched by post modernist hands but …I don't know so I'm going to pretend it's not because post modernism even if it is] Along with the way narration is taking place,  the tone that carries the stories out are very casual. Both Reed and Doctorow seem to tell certain big events in a casual tone; maybe to emphasis it more or make it seem not as important as the story the authors are trying to tell. There is also this feeling of skepticism towards authority that arises as I read these books. Reed went as far as saying that a secret society was controlling things while Doctorow makes a fool of the police forces and how injustice the justice system was back then. The main idea that really connects these two stories for me is the idea of big cultural changes in America is represented in these stories. My interpretation of Ragtime allows me to say that hey, America's changing and this is how it's affecting its civilians; we end up with a totally different dynamic, and dare I say ideal, than we started in the beginning. Of course I'm jumping ahead of myself by assuming that maybe Mumbo Jumbo will play out the same way-- there is this great sense and need for a cultural change that is being oppressed by the higher up powers-- but I couldn't help this need to point out the similarities. 

I understand that there are dramatic differences between the two also, but I'm not pointing it out because  I'm not going to undermine my own idea. But nothing's stopping YOU!

1 comment:

  1. There are even further connections between the two, some more consequential than others: Younger Brother and Thor Wintergreen as "white radicals" who renounce their privileged upbringing and sabotage collections of art (Coalhouse anticipates the Mu'tafikah); Frued's visit to America is mentioned in both; Houdini appears in both (as a "thief" of Black Herman's material in Reed--but Black Herman himself is a historical figure woven into the novel's plot akin to how Doctorow treats Houdini). There are probably others that escape me right now--but you're getting a good sense of why it occurred to me to place these books next to each other on a syllabus!

    ReplyDelete